I just finished the game tonight, and thought it was pretty good. Everyone should check it out. Unlike other sequels, this one does pick up where the previous ones left off, but enough background information is given so you wont be lost
And the graphics were wonderful.. I loved the effect of the screen getting brighter when you look into light. Plays great no bugs, little disk swapping for a 4 disc game. Also, I found it to be a good length, even though others said it was kinda short.
I had mixed feeling about Arthur: his comments ranged from funny to downright cringe-inducingly bad.
My couple of gripes
: 1) I am tired of seeing the same locations over and over in adventure games, atlantis especially. Can't we have one game without atlantis appearing in it?
However, this one from 1998, so perhaps it would count as being before the others. 2) the music.. The 'theme' was great, but within the worlds, especially el dorado, the music may consist of one chord change repeated over and over.. and loudly. Was a bit repititious, but tolerable.. Still.. I give it a B+