Bioshock
Clive Barker's Undying
Dark Messiah Might & Magic
Gothic 1
Gothic 2
Might and Magic 6
Might and Magic 7
Oblivion
Quest for Glory 4
Silent Hill 2
Silent Hill 3
Vampire the Masquerade -Bloodlines
Vampire the Masquerade-Redemption

Here's my list:

Anachronox
Lands of Lore 3
Morrowind
The Witcher

Alone in the Dark 2
American McGee's Alice
Bioshock
Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver
Portal
Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
Rainbow Six: Vegas
Resident Evil 4
Shadowman
Silent Hill 2
Tie-Fighter
The Witcher
Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines

Well, not as many Fallout 3s as I would have thought so far.
Keep them coming - we are half way through

What's the cut-off date flotsam?

Well, as I haven't been playing RPGs for very long my list is short, but oooh they are such fun and these are favourites.

Gothic
Gothic 2 NOTR
Gothic 3
Harry Potter & the Order of the Phoenix
Oblivion
The Witcher
The Witcher Enhanced


Thanks for doing the lists again flotsam

Here's my list

Bloodrayne
Dungeon Keeper
F.E.A.R
Heroes of Might and Magic III
Hexen II
Knights of the Old Republic
Knights of the Old Republic II
Marathon II: Durandal
Might & Magic 7
Might & Magic 8
Might & Magic 9
Morrowind
Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

My list includes 2 PS3 only games (#6 and #8)

Dead Space
Fallout 3
F.E.A.R.
Mass Effect
Resident Evil
Resistance 2 (PS3)
Uncharted (PS3)
Witcher

Beyond Divinity
Divine Divinity
Dragonriders of Pern
Dungeon Siege 2
Ghost Master
Heretic Kingdoms: The Inquisition (aka Kult)
Indigo Prophecy (aka Fahrenheit)
Might and Magic VI
Morrowind
Quest for Glory 4
Sacred Plus
Witcher
Zanzarah

American McGees Alice
Beyond Divinity
Bioshock
Clive Barkers Undying
Diablo II
Divine Divinity
Drakan: Order of the Flame
Fable
FEAR Perseus Mandate
Heretic Kingdoms: The Inquisition
Prey
Sacred Plus
Zanzarah

Ana

Anachronox
Bioshock
Deus Ex
Fallout
Gothic 2
Half Life 2
ICO
Mafia
Planescape Torment
Portal
System Shock 2
The Witcher
Thief

Assassins Creed
Battlefield 2
Battlefield Bad Company
Conkers Live and Reloaded
Diablo II
Far Cry 2
Forza 2
Grand THeft Auto : San Andreas
Halo 2
Halo 3
Oblivion
Rock Band 2
Saints Row 2

Peter

I haven't played a whole lot of Darkside games but these are the ones I would recommend to others. Kay

Deus Ex
Fallout 1
Fallout 2
Fallout 3
Mafia
Morrowind
No One Lives Forever
System Shock 2
Thief 1
Thief 2: The Mechanical Age
Thief 3: Deadly Shadows

Hey everyubody.

I don't do RPGs, but here is my shooter list.

American McGee's Alice
Bioshock
Brothers In Arms Earned In Blood
Brothers In Arms Road to Hill 30
Call of Duty 4
Crysis
FEAR
DOOM 3
FEAR 2 Project Origin
FEAR Perseus Mandate
Half Life 2
Medal of Honor Allied Assault
Prey


joe

Hey Flotsam, can I give up one of those seven slots for the Witcher and add

Beyond Good And Evil

??

American McGee's Alice
Darkened Skye
Divine Divinity
Drakan
Heretic II
Might and Magic VI
Might and Magic VII
Oblivion
Outcast
Tomb Raider I
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation
Witcher
Zanzarah

Baldur's Gate 1
Baldur's Gate 2
Divine Divinity
Fallout 3
Gothic 1
Gothic 2
Gothic 3
Morrowind
Morrowind: Bloodmoon
Morrowind: Tribunal
Oblivion
Sacred 2
Two Worlds

Hi all and thanks trailmystic for the assistance.
Only a few days to go - cutoff is this weekend, so get listing.
Some clarification.
Having consulted those far more erudite than me on matters dark, Witcher and Witcher Enhanced will be treated as one game, and votes for Morrowind GOTY will have to be redone. As we count expansion packs as seperate games, and this is really a packaging of the original plus two expansions, for the purpose of our list it is technically 3 games.
I will amend the first post and contact the couple of people who voted for GOTY.
Thanks

Well here I go again. I strongly disagree even though I'm outnumbered. Morrowind GOTY has the complete Morrowind with the added chapters but it's still Morrowind. If you buy the expansions separately you still have Morrowind. You can't have the expansions without Morrowind so it is just an extension of the same game. In fact when you start the game with either Tribunal or Bloodmooned installed you are taken to the Morrowind launcher and you cannot go directly to either expansion you are started in Morrowind and you have to work to get to either expansion, so I still contest that they are all part of one game.

If that's the case then Sacred Gold should be treated the same way since it includes Underworld, which is an expansion. Witcher enhanced also includes two new adventures and with the latest patch includes 6 new adventures.

My point is that if you need the basic game to play anything then they should all be included in the basic game.

But what do I know I'm just old and had a bad day. You make the rules and I'll follow.

I totally agree.

Your point about Sacred Gold is right-on oldman and Sacred and Sacred Underworld should be listed individually, which is what we have done in past lists. The same goes for Morrowind, and similar games with formal, separately marketed expansions. Everyone has an opinion and while we can respect all, we can not necessarily please everyone so, as in the past the rules stand.

Here's my list. Some old ones and a few turn-based strategy games..

Divine Divinity
Diablo 1
Disciples 2 Gold
Heroes of Might & Magic 4
Heroes of Might & Magic 5
Neverwinter Nights 1
Neverwinter Nights 1: Hordes of the Underdark
Tomb Raider 1
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation

Bloodrayne
Condemned Criminal Origins
Drakensang The Dark Eye
Dark Messiah Might and Magic
Dungeon Seige II
Fable The Lost Chapters
Gothic
Gunman Chronicles
Hellgate London
Legendary
Morrowind
Sacred Underworld
Witcher

The countdown begins.
I have started the compilation, made all the more interesting by games I have never heard of. Some I just had to check out - Plants v Zombies to start with.
I will post results tomorrow night - thats in about 36 hours from now.

Thank you flotsam !!!!