I got Nigel to win the prize on my second playthrough as well.

I made sure to play the mini games a lot more frequently. I think I only played each once the first time around, as I was too involved in the story. I was also able to egg the kids in my second playthrough, even though I picked treat instead of trick, and I felt terrible about it.

I also can't wait for Blackenrock. I keep checking periodically to see when there will be an update.
