I would like to know your opinions on which Collector Editions games had the best bonus or extra play chapters that made a big difference in your feelings for the end of the game. If you finshed all of the regular chapters of a given game and realy felt that the bonus play or extra play made a big difference of your feelings about the game, that's what I'm looking for.

I'm sure we will have some folks here who can give you their opinions on this. I'm going to think about which CEs I think are the best in this regard and will get back to you.

I would have to say Sherlock Holmes, Hounds of the Baskervilles.

I agree with Flo about Hound of the Baskervilles. Love Chronicles: The Spell also sticks in my mind because the bonus gameplay was very generous compared to some of the other ones. The CE of Redemption Cemetery had a bonus section that was roughly equal in length to the previous stories. Haunted Manor: Lord of Mirrors, while mostly a HOG game (so I wouldn't recommend it unless you love HOGs), contained a bonus level that I found to be more interesting than the rest of the game. I'm also glad that I got the CE of Dire Grove because you have additional achievements to try to obtain and you also get to look for morphing objects.

I totally agree with Hounds, it had the best story and length for a CE, it took me nearly 2 hours. Dire Grove wasn't too bad either, I was just aggravated that there wasn't more answers to RTR in it. I have Phastasmat and really love it although because I bought SE, then CE, and then had to put in a new hard drive. I have played 2 demo's cause I wanted to try it again, then played half and had to restart when I bought CE and then I have to restart because of new drive. So I love the game just can't get to the last half and CE part!

Koalanut